Supreme Court sides with police in DNA swabbing of suspects

Published On: Jun 04 2013 05:35:00 PM HST

A controversial 5-4 decision Monday by the U.S. Supreme Court is being hailed as a victory for law enforcement, but a defeat for the protection of civil liberties.    

Justices ruled police in Maryland acted properly when they obtained a DNA sample from 26-year-old Alonzo King in 2009 after his arrest for second degree assault.  The genetic sample was run through a database, and led to King's conviction for rape in an attack that took place six years earlier.   

Local defense attorneys say the ruling turns the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution on its head, which prevents police from engaging in unreasonable searches.

"This decision sides with the guardians of the police state versus the defenders of individual liberties," said attorney Todd Eddins, who has represented thousands of criminal defendants.

"It's probably one of the most significant steps into the invasion of the U.S. citizens' privacy that's been made in the last 20 years," added attorney Don Wilkerson, who has nearly 20 years of experience in criminal defense litigation.  

According to Hawaii state law, county police departments can only obtain a DNA sample from someone placed under arrest if that person has a prior felony conviction.

"We check to see if they have a felony conviction.  If they do, then we check to see if they have been swabbed before, and if not, then they are swabbed," Honolulu police spokeswoman Teresa Bell told KITV4.  

Eddins and Wilkerson are split on whether the Supreme Court ruling requires Hawaii lawmakers to amend the law that covers the genetic sampling of arrestees. In its opinion, the high court said police can obtain DNA samples for a "serious offense."

"They didn't define serious and it could be defined as a felony," said Wilkerson. "But I'm in court almost every day, and I'm in court hearing prosecutors argue to the judge that a DUI is a serious arrest."

However, Eddins believes the clear reading of the Hawaii law dictates lawmakers would have to amend it before police could begin taking DNA samples from anyone who's placed under arrest.

"I see many states, not necessarily this state, but many states now enacting laws saying that anybody who's arrested for any crime needs to provide DNA evidence, and that is Orwellian," said Eddins.

Sen. Will Espero, chairman of the Public Safety Committee for the past seven years, agrees with Eddins, saying the Hawaii law would likely have to be changed. Espero believes the issue could come up during the next legislative session in January.

"People should certainly pay attention because this is about government and the oversight government will have upon its citizens," said Espero. "The citizens have to voice their opinion and let us know. Do you want it this way, or that way?"

In the majority opinion, Justice Anthony Kennedy likened DNA sampling to fingerprinting, or the taking of a mug shot. He also argued the taking of genetic material is non-intrusive, and therefore, not unreasonable.

"The fact than an intrusion is negligible is of cen­tral relevance to determining reasonableness, although it is still a search as the law defines that term," wrote Kennedy.  

The 5-4 decision made for some interesting bedfellows on the high court. Conservative justices Clarence Thomas and Antonin Scalia split their votes, with Scalia authoring the dissenting opinion.

"I doubt that the proud men who wrote the charter of our liberties would have been so eager to open their mouths for royal inspection," wrote Scalia. "I therefore dissent, and hope that today's incursion upon the Fourth Amendment, like an earlier one, will some day be repudiated."


The views expressed are not those of this site, this station or its affiliated companies. By posting your comments you agree to accept our terms of use.
blog comments powered by Disqus
  • IND vs. JAX Matt Hasselback Week 4

    Andy Lyons Getty Images

    Colts beat Jags in OT

    With franchise quarterback Andrew Luck sidelined by a shoulder injury, the Indianapolis Colts turned to their two oldest players to salvage a 16-13 overtime victory Sunday against Jacksonville in Lucas Oil Stadium.

    Kicker Adam Vinatieri's 27-yard field goal with 4:36 remaining in overtime gave the Colts (2-2) a much-needed victory. At 42, Vinatieri is the Colts' oldest player.

    Backup quarterback Matt Hasselbeck, 40, started in place of Luck and completed 30 of 47 passes for 282 yards, a touchdown and no interceptions.

    Hasselbeck's 28-yard pass to tight end Coby Fleener -- just after Jaguars' kicker Jason Myers was wide left on a 48-yard field goal that would have won it with 8:13 left -- moved the Colts into scoring position.

    Running back Frank Gore's 22-yard run set up Vinatieri's final kick.

    Jacksonville (1-3) had an opportunity to win with one second remaining in regulation, but Myers' 53-yard field goal attempt was just wide right, forcing overtime.

    The Colts wasted a golden scoring opportunity with 8:19 left in the fourth quarter when Gore fumbled at the Jaguars' 5-yard line, and defensive tackle Abry Jones recovered in the end zone. The fumble was forced by reserve safety Josh Evans and was the second by Gore coughed up in the opposing end zone this season.

    Indianapolis tied it at 13 with 12:27 to go on Vinatieri's 32-yard field goal after the Colts drove 35 yards in eight plays for the second half's first score.

    Jacksonville took a 13-10 halftime lead when Myers kicked a 32-yard field goal with four seconds remaining in the second quarter, capping a 14-play, 65-yard drive that included a 19-yard pass from Blake Bortles to wide receiver Allen Hurns to the Colts' 16.

    Indianapolis had pulled even at 10 with 6:04 left in the half on Hasselbeck's 2-yard touchdown pass to Fleener. That 13-play, 80-yard drive included five Jaguars' penalties - two pass interference calls, a roughing the passer, a personal foul and an illegal substitution.

    Bortles 8-yard TD pass to Hurns with 11:37 remaining in the half pushed Jacksonville into a 10-3 lead, capping a 49-yard drive after strong safety Johnathan Cyprien recovered a fumble by Indianapolis running back Josh Robinson. The fumble was caused by linebacker Dan Skuta.

    Each team kicked a first-quarter field goal - Vinatieri hitting from 54 yards with 4:59 left in the period and Myers from 20 yards at the 2:49 mark after Bortles completed passes of 26 and 48 yards.

    Jacksonville out gained Indianapolis 210-118 during the opening 30 minutes when Bortles was 14 of 18 for 179 yards and no interceptions. Hasselbeck completed 12 of 21 for 110 yards in the first two quarters.

    The Colts' 12 first half rushing attempts produced eight yards.

    NOTES: Colts reserve CB Jalil Brown suffered groin injury in the first half and did not return ... Jaguars MLB Paul Posluszny, who made five first-half tackles, left the game with an ankle injury in the third quarter and did not return ... Before Sunday's game, the Colts were 10-4 all-time against Jacksonville in Indianapolis ... The Jaguars were penalized six times for 47 during the opening half ... In addition to Luck, the Colts played without inactives Greg Toler (CB), Tyler Varga (RB), T.Y. McGill (DT), Denzelle Good (OT), Todd Herremans (G) and Dwayne Allen (TE) ... Jacksonville's inactives were Marqise Lee (WR), Denard Robinson (RB), Sergio Brown (S), Brandon Linder (G), Julius Thomas (TE), Chris Smith (DE) and Sen'Derrick Marks (DT).

  • Freeman fuels Falcons in win over Houston

  • Jets down Dolphins in London

  • Giants air it out in road win against Bills

  • Panthers use turnovers to beat Bucs

  • More